Make Choosing the Best Mixer for Baking Simple

All products featured on Stripes & Willows are independently selected. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Are you ready to turn your baking game up a notch? Having the best mixer for the type of baking you do regularly is an absolute must! 

Maybe you’re the cake queen in your family or every week you bake the most delicious bread for your loved ones, either way, a mixer should make your baking process easier, more fun, and actually help you create baked goods that are even better quality than normal.

The best mixer for baking is the KitchenAid Artisan 5-Quart Tilt-Head with Pouring Shield Stand Mixer it offers the best combination of quality, power, capacity, size, and price. 

My Top Picks:

Best Overall Mixer for Baking:

KitchenAid Artisan 5-Quart Tilt-Head with Pouring Shield Stand Mixer

Best Mid Range Stand Mixer for Baking:

Cuisinart Stand Mixer 5.5 Quart Tilt Head with Splash Guard Stand Mixer

Best Mixer for Baking Bread:

KitchenAid 7-Quart Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer

Best Affordable Mixer:

Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 4-Quart Stand & Hand Mixer

Best Overall Mixer for Baking:

KitchenAid Artisan 5-Quart Tilt-Head with Pouring Shield Stand Mixer

KitchenAid offers the best overall mixer for baking. From quality to functionality, to style, and even value for money KitchenAid knocks it out of the park. This iconic stand mixer is perfect for you if you’re a regular home baker (1 - 2 times per week), you are upgrading or investing for the first time, or you want a reliable stand mixer that will last an average of 10 years (assuming proper care). They are so stylish and currently come in 23 colorways!

• Type: Tilt-Head

• Capacity: 5-Quart

• Speeds: 10

• Power: 350 Watts

• Dimensions: 16"D x 16"W x 11"H

• Materials: Stainless Steel mixing bowl and attachments. Cast Zinc and Enamel structure.

• Accessories: Coated flat beater, coated dough hook, 6-wire whip, and 1-piece pouring shield. The flat beater and dough hook are dishwasher-safe.

• Price: $$$
  

Best Mid-Range Stand Mixer for Baking:

Cuisinart Stand Mixer 5.5 Quart Tilt Head with Splash Guard Stand Mixer

• Type: Tilt-Head

• Capacity: 5.5-Quart

• Speeds: 12

• Power: 500 Watts

• Dimensions: 7.87"D x 14.17"W x 14.13"H

• Materials: Stainless steel blades and bowl. Die-cast metal structure.

• Accessories: Chef’s whisk, dough hook, flat mixing paddle, and splash guard with pour spout – also included is an instruction manual and recipe book.

• Price: $$$

Best Mixer for Baking Bread:

KitchenAid 7-Quart Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer

• Type: Bowl-Lift

• Capacity: 7-Quart

• Speeds: 11

• Power: 500 Watts

• Dimensions: 14.63"D x 11.31"W x 16.5"H

• Materials: Stainless Steel mixing bowl and attachments. Cast Zinc and Enamel structure.

• Accessories: 7-Qt stainless steel bowl, double flex edge beater, coated flat beater, coated dough hook, 11-wire whip, pouring shield

• Price: $$$$$

Best Affordable Mixer:

Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 4-Quart Stand & Hand Mixer

• Type: Tilt-Head

• Capacity: 4-Quart

• Speeds: 6

• Power: 290 Watts

• Dimensions: 13.25"D x 8.2"W x 14.25"H

• Materials: Stainless Steel.

• Accessories: 5 attachments plus 4-quart stainless steel bowl. The set includes 2 traditional beaters, 2 dough hooks and whisk, and the 4 qt. bowl.

• Price: $

How to Choose the Best Mixer for Baking

When deciding on the best mixer for baking, the main thing to consider is how are you going to use your stand mixer? What kind of use is it going to get regularly? This will help you choose whether you need a tilt-head versus a bowl-lift, quality components plus overall quality (this is the main one), the best size for your kitchen (hello apartments), and price. 

Tilt-Head versus Bowl-Lift:

Basically, tilt-head is generally a good all-rounder for a home baker, they can do most recipes, are usually more compact, and come with a lot of add-ons. Bowl-lifters are better for big batches and heavy/thick mixtures (so breads, thick cookie doughs etc.) but they are larger in scale so take up more kitchen space. 

Quality:

The components where the quality will make a difference to how you use your kitchen stand are motor power (watts), attachments and bowl material, stand mixer structure material, whether parts are dishwasher safe, and features.

You want the best quality material for attachments and the bowl which is stainless steel, this happens to be dishwasher safe and non-toxic (perfect!). The stand mixer structure to not be made from plastic, this material will not last, you want a strong type of metal that will be durable and long-lasting for example die–cast metal or cast zinc with a baked enamel coating. 

Finally, you want the best power (watts) you can get without skimping on the component materials I just mentioned.

In this ultimate guide to finding the best mixers for baking, I’ll take you through what to look for when deciding on such a major kitchen investment because not only can stand mixers be pricey you’ll also ideally have it for a long time (hopefully!) so you want to make sure that your getting the right one for you, and your baking, that fits in your kitchen. It’s kinda all about you love!

From supercharged motor performance to cool features, versatility, and designs that are a breeze to use. We're even tackling burning questions, like what types of stand mixers are out there, how long they usually stick around, and whether a hand mixer or a stand mixer should be your kitchen go-to. 

Your Frequently Asked Questions Answered

What types of stand mixers are there?

Two main types of stand mixers are tilt-head and bowl-lift. Tilt-head mixers have a tilting head for easy access, versatile for various baking tasks. Bowl-lift mixers feature a stationary head with a lifting lever, suitable for larger quantities and heavy doughs, usually a professional preference or a super baking hobbyist at home.

Compact stand mixers save space with a smaller footprint, suitable for occasional baking or smaller households like apartments etc.

How long do typical stand mixers last?

Well-built ones can last 10-15 years with proper care. Factors like construction quality, materials, and brand reputation influence durability. Regular cleaning, proper storage, and adhering to maintenance guidelines extend the life. Choosing the right model for future needs is wise.

Is tilt-head or bowl-lift better?

Let's look at tilt-head and bowl-lift designs. Tilt-head mixers are small and good for small kitchens, while bowl-lift models work well if you have a lot of counter space. Think about how much you want to mix, how steady you need it, and the extra things you can add. Bowl-lift mixers are good for big batches and handling heavy or thick mixtures. Tilt-head mixers can do lots of things with different add-ons, but some bowl-lift models can do the same.

To decide, think about your kitchen size, how much you're mixing, if you need it to be steady, and what extra things you want to use. The choice depends on what you like and need for your baking.

Should I get a hand mixer or a stand mixer?

Choosing between a hand mixer and a stand mixer depends on your baking needs. A hand mixer is portable and affordable but suitable for light tasks. A stand mixer is powerful and versatile for heavy-duty baking but larger and more expensive. Consider your space, baking frequency, and budget when deciding.

Powerful Motor Performance

One key factor to consider when searching for the best mixer for baking is the power of its motor. After all, a mixer with a lackluster motor can leave you frustrated and stuck with lumpy batter or dough that just won't rise to its full mouth-watering potential. As listed above I have listed a ‘best for making bread’ mixer because we know that dough needs a super reliable piece of kitchen equipment that won’t wear your motor out too quickly. 

Whether you're kneading bread dough or mixing heavy cookie dough, a mixer with a powerful motor can handle the toughest of tasks with ease. 

These mixers are designed to provide the necessary torque and consistency to help you achieve the perfect textures and consistencies for your baked goods. 

You shouldn’t have to worry about your mixer stalling or struggling under pressure, giving you peace of mind as you whip up your yummy treats.

Additionally, a mixer with a powerful motor can handle larger quantities of ingredients, making it ideal for those who often bake in bulk or for large gatherings. You'll be able to tackle multiple recipes or double batches without feeling limited by your mixer's motor.

When considering the power of a mixer's motor, be sure to pay attention to its wattage or horsepower rating. Higher wattage or horsepower generally indicates a more powerful motor. However, keep in mind that wattage or horsepower alone doesn't guarantee superior performance. It's essential to also consider the overall construction and design of the mixer. You want the materials used to make the gears and overall stand mixer to be durable, strong, and long-lasting.

Innovative Features

One super interesting feature that many mixers for baking boast is a planetary mixing action. This unique technology ensures thorough and even mixing by replicating the movement of planetary gear systems. With the beater rotating on its axis while also moving around the bowl, every bit of your ingredients will be incorporated seamlessly. This not only saves you time but also guarantees consistent results with every batch.

Another ideal feature to consider is a tilting head. Traditionally, mixers require you to remove the bowl to access the mixing attachments or add ingredients. However, mixers with a tilting head allow you to easily lift the head, giving access to the bowl and attachments hassle-free. This simple design element makes it super convenient to scrape down the sides of the bowl or switch attachments, making your baking process less fiddly and more enjoyable.

Also, some mixers offer a built-in timer function. This feature allows you to set a specific mixing time, giving you the freedom to multitask or step away from the mixer without worrying about overmixing. 

Many mixers include various speed settings and a pulse function, this is a must when investing in such a long-term piece of kitchen equipment. These options give you full control over the mixing process, allowing you to adjust the speed according to your specific recipe requirements. Whether you need a gentle stir or a high-speed whip, having multiple speed options ensures that your mixer can help you with almost all your baking needs.

Capacity

Another key part to think about when selecting a mixer for your baking adventures is its capacity. These mixers are designed to accommodate different batch sizes.

These mixers offer varying bowl capacities, allowing you to choose the one that best suits your baking needs. 

Whether you're baking a small batch of cookies for afternoon tea or preparing a large batch of bread dough for a family dinner, these mixers can accommodate your needs. Having a mixer with ample bowl capacity means you can mix larger quantities of ingredients at once, saving you time and effort in the kitchen.

User-Friendly Design

With their flexible functionalities and strong design, these mixers are a reliable choice for any home baker looking to boost their baking endeavors. Whether you're a novice baker or a seasoned pro, user-friendly design is key to making your baking process enjoyable. 

One of the standout features of these mixers is their easy-to-use controls. A simple design makes it easy to understand and use, allowing you to adjust the speed and power effortlessly. With just a few clicks or turns of a dial, you can easily switch between different mixing tasks, such as kneading dough, whisking egg whites, or blending ingredients. 

Cleaning always feels like a chore, especially after you’ve been baking, so a mixer that is easy to clean where the designers have really considered this a must! Ideally you want removable attachments and mixing bowls that are dishwasher-safe, so that clean up is as quick as possible.

Finding the perfect mixer for your baking is crucial for enhancing your culinary creations. By considering the motor power, innovative features, versatility, and user-friendly design, you can make an informed choice that will elevate your baking experience. So, why wait? Start exploring the top mixers available today and unleash your inner professional baker. With the right mixer by your side, the possibilities for delicious creations are endless. Embrace the art of baking and let your mixer be the catalyst for your culinary journey. Happy baking!