All products featured on Stripes & Willows are independently selected. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Do you love baking? Nothing beats the aroma of freshly baked chocolate chip cookies or banana muffins wafting through your home, it makes me feel so content and relaxed when there is the smell of those delicious baked goods in the air.

But did you know that some bakeware may contain harmful chemicals that could be seeping into your food?

If you’re like me you may have been aware of this for quite some time but didn’t realize how common it is and how bad it is for you. 

My Top Picks:

Best Overall Non Toxic Bakeware:

Caraway Ceramic Nonstick 11 Piece Baking Set

Best Ceramic Bakeware:

Xtrema Ceramic 3 Piece Bakers Bundle Set

Most Budget Friendly:

GreenLife Ceramic Nonstick 12 Piece Baking Set

Best Glass Bakeware:

Anchor Hocking Glass 10 Piece Baking Essentials Set

Best Stoneware Bakeware:

Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage 3 Piece Baking Dish Set

Back in the day, I could only afford (and honestly thought it was a good idea) to purchase those old-school non-stick baking sheets or muffin tins.

You know the ones where if you accidentally scratched it the black non-stick coating would start to scratch off?

Then you could see the metal underneath!

I now cringe because I used to keep using those pieces of bakeware for a good 12-months plus before I would replace them!

Food would literally have to stick to it, no matter how much I prepped it with grease before I would consider binning it.

I’ve researched everything from toxicity, bakeware materials, to price, how eco-friendly a brand is, quality, and of course how stylish it is. So I have you covered!

Best Non Toxic Bakeware

When it comes to choosing high-quality sets ensure that you have all the necessary pieces for your baking needs. Depending on your preference there are several materials that are non toxic: ceramic, ceramic coated, stainless steel, glass, and stoneware. When choosing ceramic-coated bakeware, aluminum is a typical core material, it conducts heat well which is good for baking but the ceramic coating prevents it from leaching into your food.

Best Overall: Caraway Ceramic Nonstick 11 Piece Baking Set

The best non toxic bakeware is Caraway’s bakeware. It ticks all the boxes from the non toxic materials used, the bakeware is thoughtfully designed with you in mind including how you will actually use it, its versatility, the stylish design, and the company’s eco-friendly ethos!

Their colorway options are super modern from classic white/gold to sophisticated sage green. LOVE IT. This bakeware set is so good that typically I would add a small section for features but I’m going to give you 2 x features section!

Features 1:

• A full bakeware set including:

  • 18x13” baking sheet with stainless steel handles.

  • 18x13” stainless steel cooling rack

  • 15x10” baking sheet.

  • 12 cup muffin pan.

  • 9x13” baking pan with stainless steel handles.

  • 9” square baking pan, perfect for brownies or bars.

  • 1lb loaf pan -holds slightly more than a typical loaf pan.

  • 2 x 9” cake pans - my go-to cake pans for the perfect layer cake.

  • 2 x bespoke storage compartments - these have to be some of the most inventive and aesthetic-looking additions I’ve ever seen in a bakeware set. They are covered in a stylish light grey fabric, due to the compartments it compacts really small, which is great for apartment living. To top it off they don’t use tacky velcro instead they use stylish internal magnets to “clip” it shut.

  • Embossed cork trivets to place your hot bakeware on.

• Non Toxic: No PFAS, PTFE or PFOA.

• Material: Ceramic-coated aluminum.

• Eco-Friendly:

  • No single-use plastics.

  • Packaging is made from recycled cardboard.

  • Biodegradable cork trivets are added.

  • Caraway bakeware releases 60% less CO2 compared to traditional non-stick bakeware.

  • Ethically sourced via partnerships with BSCI & SMETA certified manufacturers.

• Features 2:

  • Non-stick ceramic coating.

  • Oven safe to 550 F.

• Price: $$$$

Read my Caraway cookware review for more info about this awesome brand!

Best Ceramic Bakeware: Xtrema Ceramic 3 Piece Bakers Bundle Set at Xtrema

The best ceramic bakeware is made by Xtrema! All their ceramics are 100% ceramic, that’s right no metal core, no metal at all so there is no risk of metals leaching into your food. Their bakeware set comes with a non toxic loaf pan, muffin pan, and pie dish.

• Non-Toxic: No Teflon, PFOA, PFAS, non-stick coats or metal core!

• Material: 100% ceramic.

• Eco-Conscious: They focus on reducing waste through their manufacturing and shipping processes.

• Features:

  • Baking set includes 6 cup muffin pan, 9” pie pan, and 2qt loaf pan.

  • Handcrafted.

  • Oven, BBQ, microwave safe.

  • Freezer safe.

  • Dishwasher safe.

• Price: $$$$$

Most Budget Friendly: GreenLife Ceramic Nonstick 12 Piece Baking Set

This brand offers a variety of non toxic bakeware sets made from ceramic and aluminum materials. The ceramic sets come in a range of bright and bold colors, making them a stylish addition to any kitchen. You get a whooping 12 items in this baking set and it is the most budget friendly!

• Non Toxic: No PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium.

• Material: Ceramic coated aluminum.

• Eco-Friendly: Recycled aluminum is used to make these bakeware, with solar panels powering 30% of their factories' needs, their bakeware releases 60% less CO2 compared to traditional non-stick bakeware.

• Features:

  • Oven safe to 450 F.

  • Utensils dishwasher safe.

• Price: $$

Best Glass Bakeware: Anchor Hocking Glass 10 Piece Baking Essentials Set

The best glass bakeware is Anchor Hocking! The brand itself embodies the American spirit, it’s been around since 1905 (insane!) and started in Lancaster, Ohio. Glass is a naturally non toxic bakeware material and using glass bakeware gives you peace of mind while also being able to see if the bottom of your pie is cooked through!

• Non Toxic: Glass made so naturally non toxic. No chemicals.

• Material: Glass.

• Eco-Friendly: Glass is 100% recyclable meaning their entire product can be recycled!

• Features:

  • Dishwasher safe.

  • Freezer safe.

  • Oven safe to 425 F.

  • Made in the USA.

• Price: $

Best Stoneware Bakeware: Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage 3 Piece Baking Dish Set

The best stoneware bakeware is Le Creuset stoneware baking set. This brand perfectly balances quality and style.

With nearly 100 years of experience Le Creuset knows their way around a kiln! Their strong pigment glazed stoneware and cast iron bakeware are the most aesthetic of my top picks.

• Non Toxic: They use their own proprietary technology which has no PTFE and PFOA.

• Material: Stoneware and enamel.

• Eco-Friendly: They have installed solar panels to supply their 300,000 square foot sized warehouse with energy!

• Features:

  • Microwave safe.

  • Dishwasher safe.

• Price: $$$ 

By investing in one of these top bakeware sets, you can have all the necessary pieces for your baking needs while ensuring that your kitchen is a safe and healthy environment.

I think we are so lucky to have access to this type of information (thank you internet) and I hope as time goes on it gets a lot easier to access this type of information to make informed decisions.

In the next section we’ll look at why non toxic bakeware is important!

Why Non Toxic Bakeware is Important

One important factor to consider when selecting bakeware is its toxicity level.

While it may not be a concern for some, those who prioritize their health and safety may want to take a closer look at the materials they use in their kitchen. 

Chemicals like BPA, lead, and cadmium are commonly present in traditional bakeware, and can potentially leach into food during cooking or baking. 

That's why non toxic bakeware is so important. By choosing non toxic materials, you can avoid the risk of harmful chemicals contaminating your food.

Additionally, non toxic bakeware can be better for the environment, as it often uses more sustainable and eco-friendly materials. 

When shopping for bakeware, it's important to look for materials like ceramic, glass, and stainless steel.

These materials are generally considered safe and have a lower risk of chemical leaching compared to materials like Teflon or aluminum. 

Chemicals to Avoid in Bakeware

When choosing bakeware, it's important to consider the potential chemicals that could leach into your food. Here are some chemicals to steer clear of in your bakeware:

1. Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) - commonly found in non-stick coatings like Teflon, PFOA has been linked to cancer, developmental problems, and other health issues.

2. Bisphenol A (BPA) - often used in plastic bakeware, BPA can mimic estrogen in the body and has been linked to hormone disruption and other health problems.

3. Phthalates - another common ingredient in plastic bakeware, phthalates have been linked to reproductive issues, asthma, and other health problems.

By avoiding materials that contain these chemicals, such as Teflon and plastic, you can help protect your health and the environment. Opt for safer materials like ceramic, glass, and stainless steel instead. 

With the knowledge of what to avoid, you'll be able to make the best choices for your toxic free bakeware needs. 

When it comes to baking, your health should always be a priority. This means avoiding toxic bakeware that can contaminate your food with harmful chemicals.

By choosing non toxic options free from PFOA, PFAS, and lead, you can bake with confidence and peace of mind. 

With the best non toxic bakeware brands, sets, sheets, tins, and pans on the market, there's no need to compromise taste for health. 

As you bake up a storm in 2023, remember the importance of choosing safe bakeware options. Your health will thank you for it!